Midwest Roofing has a perfect five-star rating across 260 reviews. Think about that. That’s a lot of homeowners who were happy enough to go out of their way and say so publicly. That kind of reputation is hard to earn, and most roofing companies never get close.
So the question is simple. Is the marketing doing that reputation justice? We went through the code behind their website to find out. What we found is what I see over and over when I review local service accounts: a great business with a leaky marketing setup.
| Finding | What the audit found | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Reviews shown but not marked up for Google | Review content on the page with no aggregateRating/review schema | Marked-up reviews can show star ratings directly in search results, which lifts click-through on a listing you already rank for — free clicks you’re currently leaving behind. |
| No service+city pages | No internal links matching a service-in-city URL pattern | People search “emergency plumber in <city>”, not “Midwest Roofing”. With one generic services page there’s nothing for Google to rank against those searches, and paid clicks land somewhere too generic to convert. |
| No analytics detected | No GA4/Google Tag Manager script found in the page source. | No way to know which marketing produces leads and which burns money. |
| No paid-ads tracking detected at all | No Google Ads conversion tag, no Meta pixel in the page source. | Either no paid acquisition, or ads running blind with no conversion measurement. |
| No Facebook/Meta pixel detected | No fbq(‘init’) / connect.facebook.net script found in the page source. | Without a pixel, there’s no way to retarget people who already visited the site — one of the cheapest ad channels available goes unused. |
The reviews are on the page, but Google can’t read them
The reviews are right there on the site. Visitors can see them. But there’s no review markup. That’s a small code snippet that labels star ratings so Google understands what they are.

With that markup in place, stars can show up right inside the search results. If this were my account with a perfect five, I’d want those stars in front of every single person scrolling past. A five-star rating next to your listing is a trust signal before anyone even clicks. Without the markup, you’ve earned the reputation but you’re not displaying it where the decision gets made.
No pages built for a specific service in a specific city
This is the big one. We didn’t find any pages built around a specific service in a specific city.

Picture someone with water dripping into a bucket on their kitchen floor. They’re not typing a company name. They’re typing something like “roof repair” plus their city, with their phone in one hand. That person has an urgent problem and wants a roofer now.
Why that gap costs you jobs
Without a page built for that search, Google has nothing specific to show them. It can’t match your site to the exact thing they typed. And it goes beyond organic rankings. If you pay for a click, that click lands on a page that’s too general to book a job. The homeowner with the bucket doesn’t want to hunt around a generic homepage. They want a page that says, in plain words, that you do exactly what they need in the place they live.
Searches with a service and a location in them come from people who are ready to act. If your site has no page that matches, you’re invisible to the people closest to paying.
No analytics means you’re flying blind
Next, there’s no analytics on the site. No Google Analytics. No tag manager. That means there’s no clean way to see which marketing brings in leads and which just burns money.

Think about what that does to your decisions. You spend on something, calls come in or they don’t, and you’re guessing why. You can’t double down on what works because you can’t see what works. For a business spending real money to get the phone ringing, that’s a problem.
No ads conversion tag: nothing records a lead from an ad
Same story with ads. We found no Google Ads conversion tag. Maybe they’re not running ads at all, and that’s fine. But if they are, I’d want every dollar measured.

Right now, nothing on the site would record a lead coming from an ad. So if a click turns into a booked roof, the ad account never learns about it. You can’t tell which campaigns or keywords earn their keep, and the platform can’t optimize toward real leads either.
No Meta pixel, so no retargeting
There’s also no Meta pixel. That’s the code Facebook and Instagram use to recognize past visitors. So picture a homeowner who checked out the site and got pulled away by the kids. Normally you could show them a friendly reminder later. Without the pixel, you can’t.

Retargeting is one of the cheapest ways to win a lead back. These people already know who you are. They already looked. Without the pixel, that option is off the table.
No video on the homepage
The homepage has no video. A short clip walking people through how a job works builds trust faster than any paragraph. It also keeps visitors on the page longer. For a company with a perfect rating, a quick video that shows the process and the team would make the reputation feel real before anyone picks up the phone. I’d add one.

These are basics, so why do agencies miss them?
None of this is advanced. These are basics. After reviewing hundreds of local service accounts, I can tell you most agencies I’ve seen miss them for one reason. They collect a monthly retainer while a junior staffer juggles 80 accounts, and nobody actually looks.

If someone’s being paid to run your marketing, they should have caught every item on this list. Any decent home service marketing agency should be checking tracking, markup and landing pages before anything else. When one doesn’t, it usually isn’t malice. It’s a model where volume beats attention.
If someone is being paid to run this, they should have caught it.
The part most owners don’t know yet
Here’s what most owners haven’t realized. With AI, these exact fixes can now run automatically. With a bit of guidance, you can bring your marketing in-house, own the whole thing, and never depend on an agency again.

That’s exactly what we build at Local Service Mastery. It’s coaching and tools for owners who want lead generation without agencies. If you want to see how your own setup stacks up, our approach to lead generation for contractors starts with finding what’s leaking before spending another dollar.
Local Service Mastery








