A perfect five-star rating across 1,988 Google reviews. After looking at hundreds of local service accounts, I can tell you that number is rare. That is years of doing the job right, with customers going out of their way to say so.
This breakdown looks at one garage door company, Anytime Garage Door. I looked only at the online marketing, not the work itself. The reputation is elite. The website sitting behind it is leaking jobs in ways most owners never see.
None of what I found is advanced. It is basic stuff, and it is exactly what a contractor pays someone to catch.
| Finding | What the audit found | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Reviews shown but not marked up for Google | Review content on the page with no aggregateRating/review schema | Marked-up reviews can show star ratings directly in search results, which lifts click-through on a listing you already rank for — free clicks you’re currently leaving behind. |
| No LocalBusiness structured data | No JSON-LD structured data at all | Structured data is how Google reads your hours, service area, phone and rating. Without it Google guesses — and competitors who publish it get the rich result instead. |
| Slow mobile site (42/100 Google PageSpeed) | Google PageSpeed mobile performance score 42/100, LCP 4.8 s. | Homeowners on phones bounce before the page loads — paid clicks included. |
| Most images missing alt text (85/85) | 85 of 85 <img> tags on the homepage have no alt attribute. | Alt text is a direct on-page SEO signal for image search — and it’s what screen readers use for accessibility. |
| YouTube channel inactive (13 months since last upload) | Their YouTube channel’s most recent video was uploaded 417 days ago. | An inactive channel signals to both viewers and Google that the business isn’t actively investing in content. |
| No social preview tags (OpenGraph) | No og:title / og:image meta tags in the page source | Every time someone shares your link in a text, Facebook or a group chat, it renders as a bare URL with no title or photo — the least clickable thing on the screen. |
| H1 heading is not the first heading on the page | A lower-level heading (H2/H3) appears in the HTML before the page’s own H1 tag. | Search engines weight heading order — burying the H1 under other headings weakens it as a ranking signal. |
The reviews are real, but Google can’t fully read them
I want to start with the reviews. The homepage shows review content, but there is no review markup behind it. Markup is hidden code that labels things for Google. Without it, those gold stars can’t appear next to the listing in search results.

Picture two garage door companies side by side on a results page. Only one has gold stars under its name. Which one gets the click?
With 1,988 five-star reviews, I would want every single one of them working in search. Right now they are doing their job on the page, but they are not helping the listing stand out before anyone clicks.
No structured data means Google is guessing
It goes beyond reviews. We found no structured data on the page at all. Structured data is the code that tells Google your hours, your service area and your phone number.

Without it, Google guesses. A competitor who spells all of that out can win the richer listing, even with fewer reviews and a weaker reputation. You earned the trust. You should not hand the better presentation to someone else because your site never said the details out loud.
The speed problem is where it really costs jobs
This is the one that hits revenue. Google’s own speed test scored the mobile site 42 out of 100. The main part of the page took 4.8 seconds to show up.

Think about who is searching. The door is stuck halfway. Their car is trapped inside. They are standing in the driveway with a phone in their hand. They are not browsing, they need someone now.
Almost five seconds of waiting is plenty of time to hit back and call the next company.
In an emergency category, speed is not a nice-to-have. A slow mobile page turns a ready-to-buy caller into a lead for your competitor, and you never see it happen. It does not show up as a complaint. It just shows up as a phone that did not ring.
85 images, zero alt text
All 85 images on the homepage have no alt text. Alt text is a short written description of a photo. Google uses it for image search. Screen readers read it aloud for visitors who can’t see the page.

That is 85 blank labels. It is a missed chance to be found, and it makes the site harder to use for some visitors. It also takes very little effort to fix, which is what makes it frustrating.
Video: silent channel, empty homepage
The YouTube channel’s last upload was 417 days ago, and the homepage has no video at all. For a garage door company, that is a wasted trust builder.

A one-minute clip of a tech explaining what a broken spring sounds like builds trust faster than any paragraph. It does not have to be the owner on camera. Maybe it is the most patient tech on the team. Customers are about to let a stranger into their home, and seeing a calm, knowledgeable person helps them make the call.
No social preview tags
The last gap is the smallest, but it is a good example of how details get missed. There are no social preview tags. When a happy customer texts the link to a neighbor, it shows up as a bare web address, with no title and no photo.

Word of mouth is the best marketing a service company gets, and 1,988 reviews tell you this business earns plenty of it. A link that looks plain and unfinished makes that referral a little less likely to turn into a click.
Why this stuff slips through
None of this is advanced. These are basics any marketing agency should catch. In most agencies I have seen, when this slips, it is usually because they collect a monthly retainer while a junior person juggles 80 accounts and nobody actually looks.

If someone is being paid to run your marketing, they should have caught it. That is the standard I would hold any home service marketing agency to, including us. If your provider cannot tell you your mobile speed score, whether your reviews are marked up, or when your last video went up, you are paying for attention you are not getting.
The fix is cheaper and faster than you think
Here is what most owners do not know yet. With AI, fixes like these can now run automatically. With a bit of guidance, you can take control, run your marketing in-house, own the whole thing, and never depend on an agency again.

That is the idea behind what we teach at Local Service Mastery. Contractors should understand their own marketing and own the assets. It should not be a black box you rent by the month. If you want to see how a system like that works, look at our approach to home service lead generation.
Local Service Mastery








