A roofing company with a 4.9 star rating across more than 1,800 reviews. After reviewing hundreds of local service businesses, I can tell you that combination is rare. Homeowners clearly love the work.
So the question is simple. Is the marketing working as hard as the crews are? I went through Amstill Roofing’s public footprint to find out. What I found is the same pattern I see over and over: great reputation, leaky marketing.
| Finding | What the audit found | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Live Google ads are publicly visible — and auditable | Google’s Ads Transparency Center lists 37 ad creative(s) linked to this business (domain/name match); creative preview URLs captured for on-screen use. | Their actual running ads are public record — reviewable on screen in the video. |
| Slow mobile site (32/100 Google PageSpeed) | Google PageSpeed mobile performance score 32/100, LCP 51.4 s. | Homeowners on phones bounce before the page loads — paid clicks included. |
| Weak local map-pack visibility (36.0% within a 5.0-mile radius) | Live Google Places search grid scan for “roofing contractor”: appears in the top-3 map pack at only 36.0% of 25 checked points around the business, average rank 4.4. | Most customers only ever see the 3-pack at the top of local search results — falling outside it across most of the checked service area means most nearby searches never surface this business at all. |
| H1 heading is not the first heading on the page | A lower-level heading (H2/H3) appears in the HTML before the page’s own H1 tag. | Search engines weight heading order — burying the H1 under other headings weakens it as a ranking signal. |
| No video content on the homepage | No YouTube/Vimeo/Wistia embed found in the page source. | Video builds trust fastest and keeps visitors on the page longer — a homepage with zero video is a missed, low-cost opportunity. |
| YouTube channel inactive (23 months since last upload) | Their YouTube channel’s most recent video was uploaded 704 days ago. | An inactive channel signals to both viewers and Google that the business isn’t actively investing in content. |
They are spending real money on Google Ads
The first thing we found is that Amstill is actively buying Google Ads. Google’s own Ads Transparency Center lists 37 live ad creatives tied to this business.
That is real money going out every month to buy clicks. And that is exactly why the next finding hurts so much.
A 51 second page load is burning the ad budget
Their website scores 32 out of 100 on Google’s mobile speed test. The biggest piece of the page takes 51.4 seconds to show up. Not 5 seconds. Fifty-one.
Think about who is clicking that ad. Someone has a leak over their head, they are searching on their phone, and they need help now. They are not waiting nearly a minute for a page to load. They hit back and call the next roofer.
Every click you pay for is a bet that the page will turn a visitor into a phone call. A slow page loses that bet before the visitor reads a single word. If this were my account, no more ad dollars go out until this page is fixed.
If the page takes 51 seconds to load, every ad dollar you spend is a donation to your competitor.
1,800 reviews and still invisible on the map
Next, we ran a live map scan across a five mile radius around the business. We searched “roofing contractor” the way a homeowner actually would.
What the scan showed
- Amstill reaches the top three map results only 36% of the time.
- Their average rank is 4.4.
- Most searchers never look past the top three.
So across most of their own service area, a company with 1,800 reviews is effectively invisible. That is the part that should wake owners up. Reviews are a huge asset, but they do not automatically turn into map visibility. Visibility has to be built and measured on purpose, and you only see the real picture when you scan the whole service area instead of checking one search from your office.
The smaller on-page problems that still tell a story
The homepage headline is backwards
On their homepage, the H1 sits in the code underneath smaller subheadings. The H1 is the main headline Google reads as the page’s title. Having it buried below smaller headings is basic on-page SEO done in reverse. It is a small fix, but it shows nobody is checking the fundamentals.
No video anywhere on the homepage
The homepage has zero video anywhere in its source code. And their YouTube channel’s most recent upload was 704 days ago. That is nearly two years of silence.
For a company with this kind of reputation, video is the fastest way to build trust with a stranger. A homeowner who has never heard of you is about to let you onto their roof. Seeing your crew, your process and your people does a lot of that trust work before they ever pick up the phone. Right now, nothing on the page is doing that job.
None of this is exotic
Here is the bigger picture. Page speed, heading order, map visibility. This is week one stuff for anyone running local marketing. None of it needs a genius to spot.
But most agencies I have seen collect the monthly retainer while a junior person juggles 80 accounts, and nobody actually looks. If someone is being paid to run this, they should have caught it. That is the real risk of renting your marketing from a typical home service marketing agency: you are paying for attention you may never get.
What an owner should take from this
- Fix the landing page before you spend more on ads. Speed is the first gate every paid click has to pass through.
- Measure map visibility across your whole service area. One search from your own phone tells you nothing.
- Check the basics. Heading structure, video and fresh content are not advanced tactics.
- Ask whoever runs your marketing what they found last month. If they cannot tell you, nobody is looking.
The reputation was earned. The marketing just is not converting it. That gap is where most local service businesses quietly lose jobs.
AI changes who can fix this
Here is what most owners do not know yet. With AI, these exact fixes can now run automatically. With a bit of guidance, you can take this in-house and own your marketing instead of renting it from an agency forever.
That is the whole reason Local Service Mastery exists. We teach service business owners to run their own lead generation, backed by Google Ads and Local SEO training for contractors and tools that automate the repetitive work an overloaded agency account manager never gets around to.
Local Service Mastery








